Wrestling

List of Extreme Rules 2009 Match Results

A complete match-by-match results list for the inaugural Extreme Rules on June 7, 2009 at the New Orleans Arena in New Orleans, Louisiana.

7 itemsUpdated Mar 24, 2026

The inaugural Extreme Rules on June 7, 2009 at the New Orleans Arena in New Orleans, Louisiana was directly established to replace the One Night Stand PPV event. It featured wrestlers from Raw, SmackDown, and ECW — the only Extreme Rules event to include ECW, which was disbanded in February 2010. Edge defended the World Heavyweight Championship against Jeff Hardy in a Ladder Match as the main event. Attendance: 11,481.

#	Name	Loser	Winner	Match type	Title change
1	Christian def. Jack Swagger — ECW Championship Ladder Match Captain Charisma Won ECW Title in Ladder Match Christian defeated Jack Swagger in a Ladder Match to win the ECW Championship — Christian had been stripped of the title earlier, and the Ladder Match was used to determine the new champion.	Jack Swagger	Christian (NEW ECW Champion)	ECW Championship Ladder Match	true
2	Kofi Kingston def. MVP, Matt Hardy & William Regal — Fatal Four-Way Kofi Won US Title in Fatal Four-Way Kofi Kingston defeated MVP, Matt Hardy, and William Regal in a Fatal Four-Way match to win the United States Championship.	—	Kofi Kingston (NEW US Champion)	United States Championship Fatal Four-Way	true
3	Batista def. Randy Orton — WWE Championship No Holds Barred The Animal Won WWE Title from Legend Killer Batista defeated Randy Orton in a No Holds Barred match to win the WWE Championship — Batista's family members were at ringside and provided motivation for his win.	Randy Orton	Batista (NEW WWE Champion)	No Holds Barred — WWE Championship	true
4	Tommy Dreamer def. Christian, Jack Swagger, Finlay & Mark Henry — ECW Title Match Dreamer Won ECW Title in 5-Way Extreme Rules Match Tommy Dreamer won the ECW Championship in a five-way Extreme Rules Match — an emotional win for the ECW original who was moments away from his ECW contract expiring.	—	Tommy Dreamer (NEW ECW Champion)	ECW Championship 5-Way Extreme Rules Match	true
5	CM Punk def. Umaga — Singles Match Straight Edge Savior Won CM Punk defeated Umaga in a singles match.	Umaga	CM Punk	Singles Match	—
6	John Cena def. The Big Show — Submission Match You Can't See Me Won in Submission Match John Cena defeated The Big Show in a Submission Match by applying the STF to the much larger opponent.	The Big Show	John Cena	Submission Match	—
7	Jeff Hardy def. Edge — World Heavyweight Championship Ladder Match Hardy Won World Title in Ladder Match — Edge Crashed Through Ladder Jeff Hardy defeated Edge (with CM Punk interfering) in a Ladder Match to win the World Heavyweight Championship — one of Hardy's most celebrated title wins. Edge crashed through a ladder during the match.	Edge	Jeff Hardy (NEW World Heavyweight Champion)	World Heavyweight Championship Ladder Match — Main Event	true

This list is compiled from verified public records and reference sources. Last verified: March 24, 2026.

Found an error? Report it here