| 1 | Shawn Michaels — WWE Hall of Famer 2011 Mr. WrestleMania — WM11 WWF Title Match Shawn Michaels was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2011 — losing the WWF Championship match to Diesel at WM11 in the best match of the night. | 2,011 | WWF Title Challenger — best match of WM11 (lost to Diesel) |
| 2 | Bret Hart — WWE Hall of Famer 2006 WM11 I Quit Match — Worst Career Match Bret Hart was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2006 — competing in the I Quit Match against Bob Backlund at WM11, which he himself has called his worst career match. | 2,006 | I Quit Match win over Backlund — Hart's self-described wo... |
| 3 | The Undertaker — WWE Hall of Famer 2022 WM11 Streak 4-0 — King Kong Bundy The Undertaker was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2022 — extending his WM streak to 4-0 at WM11 by defeating King Kong Bundy with MLB umpire Larry Young as special referee. | 2,022 | Streak 4-0 — defeated King Kong Bundy (special ref: Larry... |
| 4 | Razor Ramon (Scott Hall) — WWE Hall of Famer 2014 WM11 IC Title DQ Loss Razor Ramon was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2014 — losing the IC championship match to Jeff Jarrett via DQ at WM11. | 2,014 | IC title challenger — won by DQ but Jarrett retained |
| 5 | Roddy Piper — WWE Hall of Famer 2005 WM11 Special Referee — Prematurely Stopped I Quit Roddy Piper was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2005 — serving as special referee for Bret Hart vs. Bob Backlund's I Quit Match, controversially stopping it before Backlund said 'I Quit'. | 2,005 | Special Referee — I Quit Match (Hart vs. Backlund) |
| 6 | Owen Hart — WWE Hall of Famer 2024 Posthumous — Won First WWF Title at WM11 Owen Hart was inducted posthumously into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2024 — winning his first WWF championship at WM11 (Tag Team titles with Yokozuna), six years after his WM debut at WM5. | 2,024 | Won WWF Tag Championship with Yokozuna (mystery partner r... |
| 7 | Yokozuna — WWE Hall of Famer 2012 WM11 Tag Championship Win with Owen Hart Yokozuna was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2012 — winning the WWF Tag Team Championship with Owen Hart at WM11 as the mystery partner reveal. | 2,012 | Won WWF Tag Championship with Owen Hart (mystery partner ... |
| 8 | Lawrence Taylor — Pro Football Hall of Famer 1999 NFL Hall of Famer — WM11 Celebrity Main Event Lawrence Taylor was inducted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1999 — making his in-ring wrestling debut at WM11's main event against Bam Bam Bigelow. | — | Celebrity Main Event — In-ring debut (defeated Bigelow) |
| 9 | Ted DiBiase — WWE Hall of Famer 2010 WM11 Million Dollar Corporation Manager Ted DiBiase was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2010 — managing the Million Dollar Corporation at WM11 (Bigelow vs. Taylor, Bundy vs. Undertaker). | 2,010 | Million Dollar Corporation manager — Bigelow and Bundy bo... |
| 10 | Diesel (Kevin Nash) — WWE Hall of Famer 2015 WM11 Retained WWF Championship Diesel was inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame in 2015 as part of the nWo — retaining the WWF Championship against Shawn Michaels at WM11 in the best match of the event. | 2,015 | Retained WWF Championship vs. Shawn Michaels (best match ... |