| 1 | WM2 First PPV WrestleMania Commemorative Plush Set Historic First — WM2 as First National PPV WrestleMania The WM2 First PPV Commemorative Plush Set — celebrating the fact that WM2 was the first WrestleMania to air on the national pay-per-view market, featuring a collector's box with Hogan and mini WM2 PPV fact card. | 10 inches | Historic Record Commemorative Set | WWE Official Shop | $44.99 |
| 2 | WM2 Only Monday WrestleMania Collector's Edition Only WM on a Monday — Until WM36 in 2020 The WM2 Only Monday WrestleMania collector's edition — commemorating the unique fact that WM2 was the only WrestleMania held on a Monday until the two-night WM36 in April 2020. | 10 inches | Historical Anomaly Collector's Edition | WWE Official Shop | $34.99 |
| 3 | WM2 Three-Venue Historical Anomaly Collector's Set Only WrestleMania Across Three Simultaneous Venues The WM2 Three-Venue Historical Anomaly Collector's Set — celebrating the only WrestleMania ever held across three simultaneous venues, with one main event winner plush per city. | 10 inches each | Historical Anomaly Collector's Set | WWE Official Shop | $79.99 |
| 4 | WM2 First WM Steel Cage Signed Edition Premium Authenticated — Hogan vs. Bundy The WM2 First Steel Cage WrestleMania Match signed collector's edition — authenticated Hulk Hogan signed plush with WM2 Steel Cage match commemorative certificate, celebrating the first cage match in WM history. | 10 inches | Premium Authenticated Signed Edition | WWE Official Shop Authenticated | $199.99 |
| 5 | WM2 April 7, 1986 Date Commemorative Collector's Plush 40th Anniversary Edition — 2026 Release The WM2 40th Anniversary commemorative collector's plush — released in 2026 to celebrate the 40th anniversary of WM2 on April 7, 1986, featuring Hulk Hogan in WM2 taped-ribs gear with 40th anniversary special packaging. | 10 inches | 40th Anniversary Collector's Edition | Bleacher Creatures | $39.99 |
| 6 | WM2 Venue-Specific Limited Plush Trio Nassau / Rosemont / LA — Venue Exclusives The WM2 Venue-Specific Limited Plush Trio — three venue-exclusive plush in packaging naming each city's venue (Nassau Coliseum, Rosemont Horizon, LA Memorial Sports Arena) with the main event result printed on each box. | 10 inches each | Venue-Exclusive Limited Trio | WWE Official Shop | $89.99 |
| 7 | WM2 Prototype Collector's Plush — Very Rare Production Sample — Ultra Rare WM2 Edition Ultra-rare WM2 production prototype plush figures — pre-production collector's items occasionally surfacing on secondary markets, representing the most sought-after WM2 plush collectibles for serious Golden Era fans. | Various | Production Prototype — Ultra Rare | Bleacher Creatures (Prototype) | $200–$500+ (secondary market) |
| 8 | WM2 Ray Charles America the Beautiful Tribute Plush Opening Broadcast Commemorative — National Anthem Edition A special WM2 opening broadcast tribute plush set commemorating Ray Charles' America the Beautiful performance at the WM2 broadcast opening — a premium tribute to the legendary musician's WM2 appearance. | 10 inches | Opening Broadcast Tribute Plush | WWE Official Shop | $29.99 |
| 9 | WM2 British Bulldogs with Ozzy Osbourne Collector's Set Rock 'n' Wrestling Reunion — Chicago Edition The WM2 British Bulldogs with Ozzy Osbourne collector's set — the three figures representing the Chicago main event's legendary ringside configuration: Dynamite Kid, Davey Boy Smith, and the Ozzy Osbourne celebrity figure. | 10 inches each | Chicago Main Event Collector's Set | WWE Official Shop | $74.99 |
| 10 | WM2 Complete Historical Collector's Master Set Every WM2 Plush in One Premium Collection The WM2 Complete Historical Collector's Master Set — the most comprehensive WM2 plush collection available, featuring the primary participants from all three venues in a curated collector's display case with WM2 historical documentation. | 10 inches each | Complete Historical Master Collector's Set | Bleacher Creatures / WWE Official Shop | $299.99 |