| 1 | Andre the Giant WM2 Battle Royal Winner 10" Plush Winner — Last Eliminated Bret Hart Andre the Giant's WM2 Battle Royal winner 10-inch plush — celebrating his victory in the historic 20-man WWF vs. NFL Battle Royal at Chicago's Rosemont Horizon, where he last eliminated Bret Hart to win. | 10 inches | WM2 Battle Royal Winner Plush | Bleacher Creatures | 20-Man WWF vs. NFL Battle Royal |
| 2 | William 'Refrigerator' Perry WM2 NFL Plush The Fridge — Chicago Bears NFL Star at WM2 William 'The Refrigerator' Perry's WM2 novelty plush — the beloved Chicago Bears defensive tackle who participated in the WM2 Battle Royal and famously double-crossed Big John Studd by eliminating him after a handshake. | 10 inches | WM2 NFL Participant Plush | WWE Official Shop | — |
| 3 | Bret Hart WM2 Battle Royal 10" Plush The Hitman — Final WM2 Elimination Bret Hart's WM2 Battle Royal 10-inch plush — commemorating his WrestleMania debut in the Battle Royal where he was the final wrestler eliminated by Andre the Giant, beginning a WM debut appearance that would eventually lead to one of wrestling's greatest careers. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Plush | Bleacher Creatures | 20-Man Battle Royal |
| 4 | Jim Neidhart WM2 Battle Royal 10" Plush The Anvil — WM2 Debut Battle Royal Jim 'The Anvil' Neidhart's WM2 10-inch plush commemorating his WrestleMania debut appearance in the Chicago Battle Royal alongside tag partner Bret Hart. | 10 inches | WM2 Debut Plush | Bleacher Creatures | 20-Man Battle Royal |
| 5 | WM2 Battle Royal Winner 2-Pack — Andre & Refrigerator Perry Giant vs. NFL's Biggest Star The WM2 Battle Royal 2-pack featuring Andre the Giant and William 'The Refrigerator' Perry — the two biggest physical presences in the historic WWF vs. NFL clash at Chicago's Rosemont Horizon. | 10 inches each | Battle Royal 2-Pack | WWE Official Shop | — |
| 6 | Big John Studd WM2 Battle Royal 10" Plush Double-Crossed by Refrigerator Perry Big John Studd's WM2 10-inch plush — the massive wrestler who entered the Battle Royal with a chip on his shoulder against NFL players but was famously double-crossed and eliminated by the Refrigerator Perry after agreeing to shake hands. | 10 inches | WM2 Battle Royal Plush | Bleacher Creatures | — |
| 7 | WM2 NFL Participant Mini Plush Set — All 8 NFL Players All Eight NFL Battle Royal Participants The WM2 NFL participant mini plush set — commemorating all eight NFL players who participated in the historic WM2 Battle Royal: Jimbo Covert, Harvey Martin, Ernie Holmes, Bill Fralic, Russ Francis, Jim Covert, Darryl Dawkins, and William Perry. | 6 inches each | WM2 NFL Participant Mini Set | WWE Official Shop | — |
| 8 | Hillbilly Jim WM2 Battle Royal 10" Plush Fan Favourite — Chicago Battle Royal Hillbilly Jim's WM2 10-inch plush commemorating the beloved country character's participation in the Chicago Battle Royal — a fan-favourite entry that gave the match some levity. | 10 inches | WM2 Battle Royal Plush | Bleacher Creatures | — |
| 9 | Andre the Giant WM2 Battle Royal 24" Bleacher Buddy The Giant — Supersized Battle Royal Winner Andre the Giant supersized 24-inch Bleacher Buddy in his WM2 Battle Royal winner appearance — the largest format available for the man who was literally the biggest participant in the historic Chicago Battle Royal. | 24 inches | WM2 Battle Royal Bleacher Buddy XL | Bleacher Creatures | WM2 20-Man NFL vs. WWF Battle Royal |
| 10 | WM2 Battle Royal Historic Collector's Display Box WWE vs. NFL — Limited Commemorative Edition The WM2 Battle Royal historic collector's display box — featuring mini plush of the winner (Andre), most famous NFL participant (William Perry), and the last eliminated WWF participant (Bret Hart) with a commemorative WM2 Battle Royal event card replica. | Mixed mini display | Collector's Display Box | WWE Official Shop | — |