| 1 | Tatanka def. Shawn Michaels — IC Title (Count-Out) WWF Intercontinental Championship — Michaels Retained via Count-Out Tatanka defeated WWF Intercontinental Champion Shawn Michaels (with Luna Vachon) by count-out at 18:13 — Michaels retained the IC title as championships cannot change on count-out. Sensational Sherri came to ringside to prevent Luna from interfering, and after the match Luna attacked Sherri. | 18:13 | Tatanka (via count-out) | WWF IC Championship Match | Luna attacked Sensational Sherri |
| 2 | The Steiner Brothers def. The Headshrinkers Tag Team Match — Only WM Appearance for Steiners The Steiner Brothers (Rick and Scott Steiner) defeated The Headshrinkers (Samu and Fatu, managed by Afa) at 14:22 — widely considered the best match of WrestleMania 9 and the Steiner Brothers' only WrestleMania appearance. | 14:22 | — | Tag Team Match | — |
| 3 | Doink the Clown def. Crush Grudge Match — Second Doink Interference Doink the Clown (Matt Borne) defeated Crush at 8:28 — with the assistance of a second Doink (played by Steve Keirn) who emerged from under the ring to assist when the referee was distracted. The infamous double-Doink finish confused and entertained the crowd in equal measure. | 8:28 | Doink the Clown (Matt Borne) | Singles Grudge Match | — |
| 4 | Razor Ramon def. Bob Backlund Singles Match — 3:45 Razor Ramon (Scott Hall) defeated Bob Backlund in a short singles match at 3:45 — one of the briefer competitive matches on the WM9 card. | 3:45 | Razor Ramon (Scott Hall) | Singles Match | — |
| 5 | Money Inc. def. Mega-Maniacs — Tag Title (DQ) WWF Tag Team Championship — Money Inc. Retained via DQ Money Inc. (Ted DiBiase and Irwin R. Schyster, the champions) defeated The Mega-Maniacs (Hulk Hogan and Brutus Beefcake, managed by Jimmy Hart) by disqualification at 18:27 — Jimmy Hart turned on Money Inc. and hit DiBiase with the megaphone, but the DQ meant Money Inc. retained the titles. | 18:27 | — | WWF Tag Team Championship Match | — |
| 6 | Lex Luger def. Mr. Perfect Singles Match — Steel Plate Forearm Controversy The Narcissist Lex Luger defeated Mr. Perfect in a singles match — Luger's finishing steel-plated Running Forearm was promoted as an illegal weapon due to his surgically implanted steel plate. Perfect and Luger feuded through SummerSlam 1993. | — | Lex Luger (The Narcissist) | Singles Match | — |
| 7 | The Undertaker def. Giant Gonzalez — by DQ Undertaker's Streak 3-0 — Chloroform Attack DQ The Undertaker (managed by Paul Bearer, with a live vulture) defeated Giant Gonzalez (managed by Harvey Wippleman) by disqualification at 7:33 — Gonzalez used a chloroform-soaked cloth to render the Undertaker unconscious, causing the DQ. The only DQ victory in the Undertaker's WM streak. | 7:33 | The Undertaker (Streak 3-0 — via DQ) | Singles Match — Special Streak Match | — |
| 8 | Yokozuna def. Bret Hart — WWF Championship Scheduled Main Event — WWF Championship Change Yokozuna (managed by Mr. Fuji) defeated WWF Champion Bret Hart at 8:55 to win the WWF World Heavyweight Championship — Mr. Fuji threw salt in Hart's eyes during the match, allowing Yokozuna to deliver the Banzai Drop for the win. This was the scheduled main event. | 8:55 | Yokozuna (NEW WWF Champion) | WWF World Heavyweight Championship — Scheduled Main Event | — |
| 9 | Hulk Hogan def. Yokozuna — WWF Championship (IMPROMPTU) Unadvertised Shortest Main Event in WM History — 22 Seconds In an unadvertised, impromptu match immediately following Yokozuna's title win, Hulk Hogan defeated Yokozuna (with Mr. Fuji) to win the WWF World Heavyweight Championship in approximately 22 seconds — Mr. Fuji threw salt at Hogan which missed and hit Yokozuna, Hogan hit the Leg Drop to win. | ~22 seconds | Hulk Hogan (NEW WWF Champion — 4th reign) | WWF World Heavyweight Championship — IMPROMPTU/UNADVERTISED | — |