| 1 | Cody Rhodes WrestleMania 40 Plush Finishing the Story — WM40 Gear Cody Rhodes in his WrestleMania 40 ring gear, celebrating the historic Undisputed WWE Championship win that completed his legendary story. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Special Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania 40 |
| 2 | Roman Reigns WrestleMania 38 Special Plush Tribal Chief — WM38 Gear Roman Reigns in his WrestleMania 38 ring gear celebrating the Winner Take All match against Brock Lesnar that unified the WWE titles. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Special Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania 38 |
| 3 | Hulk Hogan WrestleMania III Special Plush Body Slam — WM3 Commemorative Hulk Hogan in his WrestleMania III ring gear commemorating the historic Andre the Giant body slam in front of 93,000 fans at the Pontiac Silverdome. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Commemorative | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania III |
| 4 | The Rock WrestleMania X-Seven Plush The Great One — WM17 Gear The Rock in his WrestleMania X-Seven ring gear celebrating the greatest WrestleMania event of all time and his iconic clash with Steve Austin. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Special Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania X-Seven |
| 5 | Undertaker WrestleMania Streak Plush 21-0 — The Streak Commemorative The Undertaker in his WrestleMania 25 ring gear commemorating the greatest WrestleMania performance in history — the 5-star classic against Shawn Michaels. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Commemorative | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania XXV |
| 6 | Daniel Bryan WrestleMania 30 Plush YES! YES! YES! — WM30 Triumph Daniel Bryan in his WrestleMania 30 ring gear celebrating the underdog's greatest triumph — winning the WWE Title in the main event of WrestleMania XXX. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Special Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania XXX |
| 7 | Becky Lynch WrestleMania 35 Plush The Man Wins All the Gold — WM35 Becky Lynch in her WrestleMania 35 gear celebrating her historic double title win in the first-ever women's main event at WrestleMania. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Women's Special Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania 35 |
| 8 | Steve Austin WrestleMania X-Seven Plush Austin 3:16 — WM17 Heel Turn Stone Cold Steve Austin in his WrestleMania X-Seven ring gear commemorating the shocking heel turn and defining moment of the Attitude Era's final chapter. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Special Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania X-Seven |
| 9 | Edge WrestleMania Return Plush 2021 Rated-R Superstar Returns — WM37 Edge in his WrestleMania 37 ring gear celebrating his triumphant return from retirement and Universal Championship match at WrestleMania. | 10 inches | WrestleMania Return Edition | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania 37 |
| 10 | CM Punk & Cody Rhodes WrestleMania 42 Plush 2-Pack Road to WM42 — Rival Bundle A special WrestleMania 42 two-pack plush bundle featuring CM Punk and Cody Rhodes in their confirmed WM42 ring gear ahead of their championship showdowns in Las Vegas. | 10 inches each | WrestleMania 42 Pre-Release Bundle | Bleacher Creatures | WrestleMania 42 |